-
RSS Follow Become a Fan

Recent Posts

Free to Obey
Criticizing Candidates Who Want to Grow Government
Some Thoughts on Civility Among Minnesota Republicans
President Obama’s American Nightmare
The War on Students?

Categories

Adam Kinzinger
Adam Weigold
Affordable Care Act
Agenda 21
Al DeKruif
Al-Qaeda
American Enterprise Institute
America's Future Foundation
Amy Koch
Andrea Kieffer
Andrea Mitchell
Ann Coulter
Apple
Arlen Specter
Arne Carlson
Atlas Shrugged
Bad Legislators
Bad Republicans
Barack Obama
Barbara Banian
Bashar al-Assad
Ben Ginsberg
Ben Golnik
Ben Shapiro
Ben Wiener
Benghazi
Bill Jungbauer
Bill Paxon
Bill Pulkrabek
Bitcoin
Bloopers
Bob Barr
Bob Corker
Bob Davis
Bob Gunther
Bobby Joe Champion
Book Reviews
Branden Petersen
Brandon Petersen
Brandon Sawalich
Brian Johnson
Bron Scherer
Brookings Institution
Budget Control Act
Carla Nelson
Cato Institute
Caucuses
CCHF
Chamber of Commerce
Charles Chaput
Charlie Rangel
Chip Cravaack
Chris McDaniel
Christine O'Donnell
Claire Robling
Climate Change
Conservatism
Cynthia Lummis
Dan Hall
Dan Severson
Dave Senjem
David Fitzsimmons
David Sturrock
Department of Justice
Department of Labor
Diane Johnson
Dick Armey
Donald Trump
Ed Morrissey
Education
Edward True
Erick Erickson
Erika Harold
Evie Axdahl
Federal Budget
Francesca Chambers
FreedomWorks
Gambling
Gay Marriage
General Electric
Geoff Michel
Global Warming
Good Legislators
Greg Davids
Growth & Opportunity
Growth and Opportunity Report
Haley Barbour
Harry Reid
Henry Barbour
Heritage Foundation
Hilda Solis
House Amendment 111
Iowa Caucus
Iowa Republican Party
IRS
Jabhat al-Nusra
Jake Duesenberg
Janet Beihoffer
Jason Chaffetz
Jason Lewis
Jeff Bingaman
Jeff Flake
Jeff Johnson
Jim Abeler
Jim Oberstar
Jim Taylor
Joe Scarborough
John Blatnik
John Boehner
John Chafee
John Cornyn
John Gilmore
John Howe
John King
John Kline
John Kriesel
John McCain
John Nolte
John Yoo
Julianne Ortman
Julie Rosen
Katrina Pierson
Keith Downey
Keith Ellison
Kelly Fenton
Keystone XL
King Banaian
KTLK
Kurt Bills
Kurt Daudt
Kurt Zellers
Labor Department
Laura Ingraham
Liberal Republicans
LightSquared
Linda Killian
LookTrueNorth
Lost Generation
Marco Rubio
Margaret Cavanagh
Marianne Stebbins
Mark Buesgens
Mark Dayton
Mark Foley
Mark Kennedy
Mark Meadows
Martin O'Malley
Marty Seifert
Mary Franson
Maryland
Matt Dean
Matthew Feeney
Media Bias
Mercatus Center
Michael Brodkorb
Michael Cummins
Michael Gerson
Michael Kubesh
Michael Mukasey
Michele Bachmann
Mike Benson
Mike Osskopp
Mike Parry
Mike Sommers
Minimum Wage
Minnesota Budget
Minnesota Conservatives
Minnesota Legislature
Minnesota Republican Party
Mitch Berg
Mitch McConnell
Mitch Pangerl
Mitt Romney
MNGOP
Morrie Lanning
Nancy Pelosi
NARAL
Neal Peterson
New York Times
Newsbusters
Newt Gingrich
Norm Coleman
Norm Ornstein
NSA
ObamaCare
OccupyDC
Office of Fossil Energy
Orrin Hatch
Pat Anderson
Pat Buchanan
Pat Garofalo
Pat Shortridge
Paul Demko
Paul Gosar
Paul Koering
Paul Krugman
Paul Teller
Pete Hegseth
Pete Nelson
Pete Sessions
Peter King
Phil Krinkie
Pine City
Pine County
Pine County Republicans
Politics in Minnesota
President 2012
Racino
Rand Paul
Ravi Zacharias
Reason Magazine
Redistricting
Reince Priebus
Renee Ellmers
Republican Liberty Caucus
Republican National Convention
Republican Party of Minnesota
Republican Study Committee
Rich Murray
Rick Nolan
Rick Perry
Rick Santorum
Rick Weible
RNC
Rod Hamilton
Rodney Davis
Roger Crawford
Ron Carey
Ron DeSantis
Ron Erhardt
Ron Latz
Ron Paul
Rory Koch
RSC
Rudy in the Media
Ryan Winkler
Ryan-Murray
Scott Dibble
Scott Honour
Sean Duffy
SEIU
Sharon Angle
Simply Right
Simpson-Bowles
Socialists
Solar Power
Solyndra
Stadium
Star Tribune
State of the GOP
Steny Hoyer
Steve Gottwalt
Steve Hensley
Steve Jobs
Steve Largent
Steve Perkins
Steve Scalise
Steve Smith
Steven Chu
Sue Jeffers
Syria
Tad Jude
TARP
Tarryl Clark
Tax Foundation
Taxes
Taxpayers' League of Minnesota
Tea Party
Ted Cruz
Ted Lovdahl
Terry McCall
Thad Cochran
Thomas Mann
Thomas Miller
Thomas Sowell
Tim Cook
Tim Faust
Tim Griffin
Tim Huelskamp
Tim Kelly
Tim Pawlenty
Tobacco Taxes
Todd McIntyre
Tom Clougherty
Tom Coburn
Tom DeLay
Tom Emmer
Tom Graves
Tom Harkin
Tom McClintock
Tony Sutton
Trans-Alaskan Pipeline
Twila Brase
Unemployment
Unions
Vin Weber
Virginia Foxx
Walter Mondale
Warren Buffett
Wilfare
William McBridge
Yvonne Prettner Solon
Zygi Wilf
powered by

Rudy Takala's Columns

Hegseth & Emmer's Candidates Fall Flat

State legislative candidates selected for assistance by former senatorial candidate Pete Hegseth’s “Minnesota PAC” (MNPAC) slightly outperformed those selected by former gubernatorial candidate Tom Emmer’s “A Stronger Minnesota” on election night. Where all four of Emmer’s PAC selections fell short, two of Hegseth’s twelve candidates were able to claim victory. Yet for conservatives, there may have been a more concerning aspect to Hegseth’s choices.

In a September 10th e-mail to Minnesota Republican delegates announcing his MNPAC, Hegseth asked for money and time to help out six candidates he had chosen for the House and six for the Senate. For the House, it was Deb Kiel (1B), Carolyn McElfatrick (5B), Ben Wiener (11B), King Banaian (14B), Dan Kaiser (24B), and Russ Bertsch (42A). For the Senate, the candidates were Steve Nordhagen (SD1), John Pederson (SD14), Ben Kruse (SD36), Pam Wolf (SD37), Daivd Gaither (SD44) and Ted Lillie (SD53). The only two to win on Tuesday were Deb Kiel and John Pederson.
 
An October 4th e-mail to delegates from A Stronger Minnesota soon followed Hegseth’s with an announcement that Tom Emmer had joined the PAC. The group selected four candidates for the Minnesota House to assist. They were Chris Kellett (10A), Melissa Valeriano (25B), Andrew Reinhardt (36B), and Mandy Benz (37A). All four lost.
 
As many Republicans remember, Hegseth ran an intense campaign for the party’s 2012 senatorial nomination against Rep. Kurt Bills. Many establishment Republicans were supportive of Hegseth; the co-chair of Romney’s Minnesota campaign, Anne Neu, served as his campaign manager. One loud complaint those establishment folks made during the campaign was that they were afraid that neither conservative members of the party nor Ron Paul supporters would support Hegseth if he won the nomination.
 
One April 18th e-mail from Ms. Neu said that Ron Paul supporters were not supporting some (unspecified) legislative candidates. The e-mail stated, “This is not what the Republican Party is about,” and went to on to suggest that this description included Kurt Bills, saying, “It appears that Kurt Bills was hand-picked by the Ron Paul establishment to be the face of the movement in MN."
 
After the party endorsed Kurt Bills during an endorsing convention that saw Hegseth come in third with fifteen percent of the vote, many in Hegseth’s camp refused to support Bills. In the Republican primary, Bills lost to a nameless candidate in the first and seventh congressional districts of Minnesota. He did, of course, win the second, third, fourth, fifth, sixth and eighth.
 
The contrast between Bills’ supporters and his non-supporters was clear in my House district, 11B, which encompasses Pine & Kanabec counties. Pine County, which has a more conservative Republican Party, gave Bills 44 percent of the vote to 40 percent for the second-place finisher. Kanabec County, which has a more liberal Republican Party, voted Bills down, giving him 34 percent of the vote to 48 percent for the other candidate.
 
I thought it was especially unusual to see my district’s Republican House candidate, Ben Wiener, on Facebook stating that former Democratic Sen. Paul Wellstone had been a better Senator than Kurt Bills had the potential to become. One article he linked to on Daily Kos made the statement, “Wellstone, unlike Bills, actually knew some things.... Perhaps Bills is actually providing a service by exposing the nutty philosophy taking over the GOP before it's being pushed by a candidate with a chance to win.”
 
Do you remember that Hegseth’s PAC chose the 11B House candidate as one to support? Pondering this in retrospect prompted me to look at some additional numbers.
 
In spite of winning Pine County, Bills lost the election in my House district due to Kanabec County – and potentially due to the district’s Republican House candidate. Bills received 39 percent of the vote in the district to his opponent’s 44 percent.
 
Looking at the other five House districts selected by Hegseth’s PAC, Bills lost the primary election in two more of them. In incumbent Rep. Carolyn McElfatrick’s district 5B, Bills received 39 percent of the vote to 44 percent for his challenger. In incumbent Rep. Deb Kiel’s district 1B, Bills received 37 percent of the vote to his opponent’s 47 percent. Out of all Hegseth’s choices for House, Bills lost in three of the districts and won in three in the primary.
 
In contrast, Bills won the primary election in three of the districts represented by House candidates selected by Emmer’s PAC. He tied in one district. That was especially notable in one of the districts.
 
In Melissa Valeriano’s 25B, he won 49 percent of the vote to 37 percent for his opponent. That district falls in the first congressional district, where Bills actually lost by 26 votes out of 17,000 cast. Valeriano, who was a very conservative candidate, seems to have had a strong positive impact on Bills’ candidacy in her district.
 
In Chris Kellett’s 10A, Bills tied his opponent with 42 percent of the vote. That margin was identical to his margin in the encompassing eighth congressional district. On average, Bills over performed in state House districts represented by candidates selected by Emmer’s PAC.
 
A lot of questions come to my mind. Did a lot of MNPAC’s candidates criticize Kurt Bills, or, for that matter, the conservative movement as a whole? Could it have damaged their prospects and the prospects of other Republicans?
 
If that was the case, it was an extension of a national problem within the Republican Party. One side sees the path to electoral success as one defined by an adherence to the ideas of limited government. The other believes in displacing conservatives with people who are more concerned with just simply winning for its own sake. Ironically, the latter group would rather lose than work with conservatives to win. In a majority of cases, they unfortunately got their wish last Tuesday evening.

0 Comments to Hegseth & Emmer's Candidates Fall Flat:

Comments RSS

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Website:
Comment:
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment
Website Builder provided by  Vistaprint