RSS Follow Become a Fan

Recent Posts

Q&A with Sen. Tom Cotton
Q&A with Sen. Ron Wyden
Q&A with Rep. Louie Gohmert
Q&A with Rep. Ted Lieu
Q&A with Sen. Tim Scott


Adam Kinzinger
Adam Weigold
Affordable Care Act
Agenda 21
Ajit Pai
Al DeKruif
American Enterprise Institute
American Legislative Exchange Council
America's Future Foundation
Amy Koch
Andrea Kieffer
Andrea Mitchell
Ann Coulter
Arlen Specter
Arne Carlson
Atlas Shrugged
Bad Legislators
Bad Republicans
Barack Obama
Barbara Banian
Bashar al-Assad
Ben Ginsberg
Ben Golnik
Ben Wiener
Beth Cobert
Bill Jungbauer
Bill Paxon
Bill Pulkrabek
Bob Barr
Bob Corker
Bob Davis
Bob Gunther
Bobby Joe Champion
Book Reviews
Branden Petersen
Brandon Petersen
Brandon Sawalich
Brian Johnson
Bron Scherer
Brookings Institution
Budget Control Act
Carla Nelson
Cass Sunstein
Cato Institute
Chamber of Commerce
Charles Chaput
Charlie Rangel
Chip Cravaack
Chris McDaniel
Christine O'Donnell
Christopher Painter
Civil Forfeiture
Claire Robling
Climate Change
Common Cause
Cynthia Lummis
Dan Hall
Dan Severson
Dave Brat
Dave Senjem
David Fitzsimmons
David Sturrock
Department of Justice
Department of Labor
Diane Johnson
Diane Rehm
Dick Armey
Donald Trump
Ed Morrissey
Edward True
Elijah Cummings
Erick Erickson
Erika Harold
Evie Axdahl
Federal Budget
Federal Communications Commission
Francesca Chambers
Gay Marriage
General Electric
Geoff Michel
Global Warming
Good Legislators
Greg Davids
Growth & Opportunity
Growth and Opportunity Report
Haley Barbour
Harry Reid
Henry Barbour
Heritage Foundation
Hilda Solis
House Amendment 111
Iowa Caucus
Iowa Republican Party
Jabhat al-Nusra
Jake Duesenberg
Janet Beihoffer
Jason Chaffetz
Jason Lewis
Jeff Bingaman
Jeff Flake
Jeff Johnson
Jeff Sessions
Jeh Johnson
Jim Abeler
Jim Oberstar
Jim Taylor
Joe Scarborough
John Blatnik
John Boehner
John Chafee
John Cornyn
John Gilmore
John Howe
John King
John Kline
John Kriesel
John McCain
John Nolte
John Yoo
Jonathan Merritt
Josh McKoon
Julianne Ortman
Julie Rosen
Justin Amash
Katrina Pierson
Keith Downey
Keith Ellison
Kelly Fenton
Keystone XL
King Banaian
Kurt Bills
Kurt Daudt
Kurt Zellers
Labor Department
Laura Ingraham
Lee Goodman
Liberal Republicans
Linda Killian
Loretta Lynch
Lost Generation
Louie Gohmert
Marco Rubio
Margaret Cavanagh
Marianne Stebbins
Mark Buesgens
Mark Dayton
Mark Foley
Mark Kennedy
Mark Meadows
Martin O'Malley
Marty Seifert
Mary Franson
Matt Dean
Matthew Feeney
Media Bias
Mercatus Center
Michael Brodkorb
Michael Cummins
Michael Gerson
Michael Kubesh
Michael Mukasey
Michele Bachmann
Mike Benson
Mike O'Rielly
Mike Osskopp
Mike Parry
Mike Pompeo
Mike Sommers
Minimum Wage
Minnesota Budget
Minnesota Conservatives
Minnesota Legislature
Minnesota Republican Party
Minnesota Tea Party Alliance
Mitch Berg
Mitch McConnell
Mitch Pangerl
Mitt Romney
Modern States Education Alliance
Morrie Lanning
Nancy Pelosi
National Security
Neal Peterson
Net Neutrality
New York Times
Newt Gingrich
Norm Coleman
Norm Ornstein
Office of Fossil Energy
Orrin Hatch
Pat Anderson
Pat Buchanan
Pat Garofalo
Pat Shortridge
Paul Demko
Paul Gosar
Paul Koering
Paul Krugman
Paul Teller
Pete Hegseth
Pete Nelson
Pete Sessions
Peter King
Phil Krinkie
Pine City
Pine County
Pine County Republicans
Politics in Minnesota
President 2012
Rand Paul
Raul Labrador
Ravi Zacharias
Reason Magazine
Reince Priebus
Religious Freedom Restoration Act
Renee Ellmers
Republican Liberty Caucus
Republican National Convention
Republican Party of Minnesota
Republican Study Committee
Rich Murray
Rick Nolan
Rick Perry
Rick Santorum
Rick Weible
Right to Work
Rod Hamilton
Rodney Davis
Roger Crawford
Ron Carey
Ron DeSantis
Ron Erhardt
Ron Latz
Ron Paul
Ron Wyden
Rory Koch
Rudy in the Media
Ryan Winkler
Scott Dibble
Scott Honour
Sean Duffy
Sharon Angle
Simply Right
Solar Power
Star Tribune
State of the GOP
Steny Hoyer
Steve Gottwalt
Steve Hensley
Steve Jobs
Steve Largent
Steve Perkins
Steve Scalise
Steve Smith
Steven Chu
Sue Jeffers
Tad Jude
Tarryl Clark
Tax Foundation
Taxpayers' League of Minnesota
Tea Party
Ted Cruz
Ted Lieu
Ted Lovdahl
Terry McCall
Thad Cochran
Thomas Mann
Thomas Massie
Thomas Miller
Thomas Sowell
Tim Cook
Tim Faust
Tim Griffin
Tim Huelskamp
Tim Kelly
Tim Pawlenty
Tim Scott
Title II
Tobacco Taxes
Todd McIntyre
Tom Clougherty
Tom Coburn
Tom Cotton
Tom DeLay
Tom Emmer
Tom Graves
Tom Harkin
Tom McClintock
Tony Sutton
Trans-Alaskan Pipeline
Twila Brase
Vin Weber
Virginia Foxx
Walter Mondale
Warren Buffett
Will Hurd
William McBridge
Xi Jinping
Yvonne Prettner Solon
Zygi Wilf
powered by

Rudy Takala's Columns

How Conservative was Dick Armey?

As referenced in my previous post, Pat Shortridge said that his career working for former House Majority Leader Dick Armey credentialed him as a real conservative. Armey clearly had sufficient credentials to be elected as a Republican, but did he really support limited government?
Shortridge, running for chair of the Minnesota Republican Prty, said that he worked for Dick Armey for over 10 years, and wrote the following of his time with Armey’s office:
I saw the good things that happen when Republicans work effectively on behalf of their principles. We spent that decade revolutionizing both the Republican Party and then the United States. We beat back a Republican establishment who had lost the will to fight for our principles, especially in the US House.
Now let’s look at some history.
In 1994, Republicans’ Contract with America included a pledge to vote on a balanced budget amendment to the Constitution and a provision requiring that all tax increases be approved by a three-fifths vote of both the House and Senate. Majority Leader Dick Armey pledged to the freshman class of (more conservative) Republicans to include both in a single piece of legislation. Unfortunately, more moderate Republicans (and some Democrats) only wanted to vote for the balanced budget amendment, because it was popular. But they still wanted to be able to raise taxes without a hassle, and did not want to vote for the three-fifths provision.
Without telling anyone, Armey took thethree-fifths provision out of the legislation. When they discovered what was happening, the conservative freshmen broke away. Reps. Mark Souder and John Shadegg led an effort to drive votes away from the balanced budget amendment if the three-fifths provision was not included; in the end, 40 conservative congressmen said they would refuse to support Armey’s move. John Shadegg at least wanted to vote on both measures at once, allow them to fail, and then vote on them individually.
Armey refused to go along with this, because it would have quickly exposed Republicans who didn’t support the Contract with America.
“We were shocked to learn they were so quick to cut the compromise. We didn’t want to begin the process by compromising,” Shadegg said in retrospect.
In order to get enough votes to keep conservatives with the Republicans on the balanced budget amendment, Speaker Newt Gingrich & Majority Leader Armey promised they would still vote on the three-fifths amendment—in 1996, the next year.
Armey, in speaking to Linda Killian for her book “The Freshmen,” said, “You never compromise onprinciple, but you do on the details.” The freshmen congressmen had “such resolve they don’t understand the practical need to bend a little here and there to serve principle.”
When Congressman Steve Largent challenged Dick Armey for the post of majority leader in 1998, conservatives who are more well-known in our present day largely supported Largent.
Senator Tom Coburn of Oklahoma,then a member of the House, said in Largent’s support, "I love Dick Armey. He's a very dear friend of mine. But when it came to standing up to Newt Gingrich, he failed us... The last two years the leadership has cowered in fear.” 
(To briefly go on a noteworthy tangent, then-congressman and present-day child molester Mark Foley disagreed with the overall mentality of the freshmen, saying, “‘Compromise’ might be a dirty word, but it’s still the only word that works.”)
Others are downright disdainful of Armey. Then-Rep. Joe Scarborough refers to him as “Dick Armey (R-Whiskey Gulch),” and in his 2004 memoir Rome Wasn’t Burnt in a Day blamed Armey for the suicide of Fox anchor Brit Hume’s son and in part for the derailment of the 1994 Republican Revolution.
When Armey learned through Hume’s reporting that Congressman Bill Paxon, not Armey, was to be many congressmen’s favored nominee to challenge Speaker Newt Gingrich, Armey turned on the movement, according to Scarborough, and began a rumor that Hume was having a gay affair with Paxon.
Scarborough wrote, “I sat at my desk, rage growing by the second toward… Dick Armey, and the sleazy business of politics... Everyone knew Armey's staff was lying.”
In sum, did Dick Armey get some votes right during his eighteen-year career in Congress? Sure. Did he beat back the Republican establishment? No. He was part of it.

2 Comments to How Conservative was Dick Armey?:

Comments RSS
raybans yalae on Friday, May 30, 2014 6:33 AM
What i don't realize is in reality how you're now not actually much more smartly-liked than you might be right now. You are very intelligent. You understand therefore considerably when it comes to this subject, made me personally consider it from so many varied angles. Its like men and women don't seem to be involved unless it is one thing to accomplish with Woman gaga! Your own stuffs nice. Always handle it up!
Reply to comment

tag link on Monday, January 05, 2015 4:33 AM
Admiring the persistence you put into your blog and in depth information you present. It's great to come across a blog every once in a while that isn't the same old rehashed information. Fantastic read! I've saved your site and I'm including your RSS feeds to my Google account.
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment
Website Builder provided by  Vistaprint